Orwell is a child of his time though. If I recall correctly he went to Spain to report on the conflict (civil war) and was so shocked(?) that he volunteered to fight against the literal Nazis.
Then getting told “put down your weapons” is the context I read into this quote.
Or to take your example: it’s about someone telling you to not fight back instead of helping safe others.
While I agree with you in times of peace and between individuals it’s more nuanced: when physically under attack your options shrink.
This is the part where this quote holds true in my opinion: When you’re confronted with a situation that already turned violent. Or, worse for me personally, I’d there is no shared common value system.
How do you mediate with someone who not only is willing to kill but has the conviction that it’s the only right thing to do?
And I don’t mean that as a rhetorical question, I have no idea … And my own moral compass is fucked up by now and spinning in circles.
Orwell is a child of his time though. If I recall correctly he went to Spain to report on the conflict (civil war) and was so shocked(?) that he volunteered to fight against the literal Nazis. Then getting told “put down your weapons” is the context I read into this quote.
Or to take your example: it’s about someone telling you to not fight back instead of helping safe others.
While I agree with you in times of peace and between individuals it’s more nuanced: when physically under attack your options shrink.
This is the part where this quote holds true in my opinion: When you’re confronted with a situation that already turned violent. Or, worse for me personally, I’d there is no shared common value system.
How do you mediate with someone who not only is willing to kill but has the conviction that it’s the only right thing to do?
And I don’t mean that as a rhetorical question, I have no idea … And my own moral compass is fucked up by now and spinning in circles.